Topic started by mkn (@ 202.174.138.7) on Mon May 5 04:19:29 EDT 2003.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
Nenjodu Kalandhidu [Film:
Kaadhal Konden (2003)]
Composer: Yuvan Shankar Raja
Inspired by the prelude of The Corrs number, 'Runaway'.
Listen to
" target="_top">http://www.iespana.es/i2fs/Nenjodu-KaadhalKonden.rm">
Nenjodu
kalandhidu
| Runaway
" target="_top">http://www.iespana.es/i2fs/Runaway-TheCorrs.rm">Runaway
[i2fs] comments: It was rather startling to see Yuvan
creating a song solely out of the prelude to the Corrs' number...the
basic tune of both the songs are actually different. But yes, Yuvan has
tried his hand at a Irish-styled track and perhaps should not have
relied on one of the most popular Irish bands around, for inspiration -
a rather easy giveaway of the source! The inspiration is very similar to
R D Burman using the prelude of Procol Harem's 'A whiter shade of pale'
for his 'Manzil' number, 'Tum ho meri dil ki dhadkan'. However, while
Pancham created a masterpiece with the limited inspiration, the quality
of Yuvan's output is debatable!
28
Manasu rendum [Film:
Kaadhal Konden (2003)]
Composer: Yuvan Shankar Raja
Lifted from the song 'A rose in the wind' by Anggun.
Listen to
rendum
rose in the wind
[i2fs] comments: I came across this information in newtfmpage and
was rather surprised over two things - first, this is the second lift of
YSR in the same movie that I had included a couple of weeks back and
second, the amount of lift in this track. Blatant and in such a way that
it puts a huge question mark over an upcoming (some may argue that Yuvan
has crossed that stage with his so-called recent hits...that's besides
the point, though) composer's creativity. Trivia note on Anggun:
Anggun (born Anggun Cipta Sasmi) is one of Indonesia's most popular musical
performers. Now settled in Paris, Anggun's debut English album, 'Snow on
the Sahara' with songwriter/ producer Erick Benzi, blend diverse sounds...traditional and
con temporary, Indonesian and Euro-American. Benzi has, in the past
worked with celebrities like Celine Dion, Algerian rai singer Cheb Khaled, and French pop legends Johnny Hallyday and Jean-Jacques Goldman.
Snow On The Sahara recalls the best of Annie Lennox in the rich instrumental textures and soaring vocals of its first single, the title song; and such choice cuts as "Over Their Walls," "A Rose In The Wind," and "Valparaiso." Anggun contributed lyrics to "On The Breath Of An Angel" and to the Indonesian-language song "Selamanya." The album closes with one of its most memorable tracks, her interpretation of the David Bowie classic, "Life On Mars."
Kadhal Kondaen was a Directly Liften album.
Yuvan Shankar Raja going to be yet another Copy Cat?
Responses:
- From: mkn (@ 202.174.138.7)
on: Mon May 5 04:25:03 EDT 2003
Listen to this original version of Manasu Rendum song : http://www.iespana.es/i2fs2/RoseInTheWind-Anggun.rm
&
Listen the orginal tune of Nenjodu Kalandhidu in the song
http://www.iespana.es/i2fs/Runaway-TheCorrs.rm
Then Tell Ur Comments guyz........
- From: - (@ 202.174.138.7)
on: Mon May 5 06:19:18 EDT 2003
Listen to this original version of Manasu Rendum song : http://www.iespana.es/i2fs2/RoseInTheWind-Anggun.rm
&
Listen the orginal tune of Nenjodu Kalandhidu in the song
http://www.iespana.es/i2fs/Runaway-TheCorrs.rm
Then Tell Ur Comments guyz........
- From: Sam (@ 217.44.93.32)
on: Mon May 5 09:07:58 EDT 2003
MKN, I heard The corrs song. Apart from the Guitar intro, the song is completely different.
Manasu Rendum is similiar but not a direct lift.
Ithukku oru thani thread tevaiya?>
- From: Anbe sivam (@ 206.102.161.11)
on: Mon May 5 10:37:57 EDT 2003
mkn,
Yes, copying is Bad. But atleast he do not copy full song like DEVA. He relies on small pieces from other composers.(Atleast in this movie)
He is a popular composer, but not genius at this point. But he has a good potential to become one. Listen to Mercury Poove from Winner. He is definitely getting matured.
As far as lifting small pieces or inspirations are concerned, ARR too has his chunk. But still we respect him, correct. For that matter, I can quote some for IR too.
So why blame this young composer, who still have whole life ahead to prove himself.
- From: mkn (@ 202.174.138.7)
on: Mon May 5 11:11:43 EDT 2003
Mercury poovae is not from the album Winner. Its from the crap album Geethai. Mercury poovae is the only better song of the album.
- From: Anbe sivam (@ 206.102.161.11)
on: Mon May 5 14:39:37 EDT 2003
mkn,
Opps. Geethai correct. Vasiyakari was also good. Other songs are okay.
- From: yelame maaya (@ 172.129.215.234)
on: Mon May 5 18:21:58 EDT 2003
I feel Geethai will be a hit. jus listen to that song by tippu, anamalai thambi naanum aada vanthen da..........wow.....terrific gaana........guy no offense, jus konjam kettu paarunga.....it has that kutthu...
ofcourse mercury poove rocks...trific song....
but my best song w'd be ...again by tippu...lyric nyabagam ila.....adi kali chiriki kali, yen kaadhu mooka killi.....goes like that.......chance eh ile ponga ...supero super......vasiyakari sucks.......haha ana athaan yenalum nala irukunu solraanga......vithiyasamana ulagam........ulaage maayam vaazhve maayam
- From: mkn (@ 202.174.138.7)
on: Tue May 6 09:58:13 EDT 2003
I expected a lot from ysr in Geethai.
But, i'm very dissappointed.
In my opinion Geethai SUCKS!!!
- From: Paran (@ 203.123.16.200)
on: Tue May 6 10:01:45 EDT 2003
Hey...
Geethai doesn't suck..
Puthiya Geethai sucks...h eh eh eh
- From: ambleen (@ 61.8.210.74)
on: Wed May 7 03:43:48 EDT 2003
U want to know what sucks?
Go to the threads of:
Parasuram
Udaya
K Virus
- From: mkn (@ 202.174.138.7)
on: Wed May 7 06:17:54 EDT 2003
so pudhiya geethai doesn't sucks?
hahahaha!!!
LOL
Udhaya is much much better when compared with Pudhiya Geethai.
Pudhiya Geethai is the worst music composed for vijay movies in recent days.
- From: dinesh (@ 210.186.42.67)
on: Wed May 7 08:10:09 EDT 2003
hey hey!! our Ambleen is here with his senceless topic.....Ambleen,get a life man!!u have no other better work then critizising arr's album??can i give u a work then???Go to Hosp,admit ur self there for about 6 months...then might come to ur sences!!!
ARR rulez!!
- From: Sam (@ 217.44.89.222)
on: Wed May 7 10:46:57 EDT 2003
Dinesh you are just a blind sheep following ARR. Please wake up tp yourself man and realsie that ARR has lost his touch long time back.
- From: style (@ 65.161.65.104)
on: Thu May 8 01:10:54 EDT 2003
Dinesh,
ARR ruling your kotte probably. You are beahving like one....hehe
- From: KSR (@ 137.73.8.176)
on: Tue May 13 07:06:03 EDT 2003
Is YSR the fellow who was walking like a duck or a man who recently had an operation for prostrate cancer in the film Poonagai Poove?
- From: Sam (@ 217.44.93.203)
on: Tue May 13 09:41:33 EDT 2003
KSR you made your point. PLease give up this nonsense now!
- From: bb (@ 12.234.176.52)
on: Tue May 13 10:17:34 EDT 2003
http://www.newtfmpage.com/forum/17550.07.23.36.html
List all pages of this thread
This thread has been closed.
Back to the Forum
Post comments
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz